QuestionIf you pay a mechanic to repair your timing belt, should this mechanic also tell me to change the balance shaft belt and balance shaft tensioner at the same time, if I am changing the water pump, timing belt and timing belt tensioner. This mechanic repaired my timing belt and after two months it stopped working. The same mechanic took the car apart after it was tested for fuel pump failure, fuel filter failure, and electrical problems and has told me that the balance shaft belt and tensioner needs to be change. Shouldn't he have changed all of that at one time? I have already asked around three mechanics and they said yes. What do you think? This same mechanic is going to try and charge me the same amount that he charged me for the first repair.
AnswerA mechanic who is looking out for your interests should advise you to replace the balance shaft belt as well. The balance shaft belt tensioner pulley sometimes fails, but I would recommend inspecting when replacing the balance shaft belt and replacing only if needed at that time.
I don't think it would be unreasonable to ask for some assistance on the repair, or perhaps receive the repairs for only the cost of the balance belt and tensioner pulley, but it's important to realize that the shop is under no obligation to recommend additional items to you.
If the shop is willing to admit they should have recommended replacing the balance shaft belt at the same time and give you a reasonable level of price reduction on the further repairs, then you could consider that a reasonable indication that they value your business and are sorry that they didn't advise you as to your best interests.
On the other hand, if they won't offer reasonable assistance and admit that they should have recommended replacing the balance shaft belt, then it's time for you to take your car elsewhere since it's clear that they aren't concerned at all about your best interests.
