Land Rover Repair: 95 Rangie gears 1 & 2 noices, kind reply, rangie


Question
I want to buy a range rover 95 2.5 DSE from a local dealer. When I drove the car, I found the change of gear 1 to 2 making noices (sounds like from gear box). However, if i first changed the gear 1 into neutral and then to gear 2, there were not noices any more. For changes of all other gears were quite clear.

My question is : is it in general a problem of gear box? or maybe it is a simple problem of clutch that I can relatively eaily handle?

Thank you very much for your kind reply.

Best,

Alex

Answer
Hi Alex,

how eager are you to buy a Rangie?  Do you know how much a new or rebuilt TG will cost you?  Even a salvaged one will be at least $2000.  And it won't stop there...a twelve year old Rangie will have other problems too.

Unless you are about to inherit this Rangie, my advice would be to move on to a newer model - one with no existing problems (that you can tell) and possibly one with a warranty greater than 30/30 (30 miles or 30 minutes).

I've heard that '95's have gear 2 problems and I can confirm this with my Disco. It's always been there and I've learned to live with it.  BUT to have more than one gear doing this... I hope you have good mechanical skills, tools and lots of time.  If your hearing the noises during the shift then you'll be working on the TG.  

Get yourself a good workshop manual and find a local LR mechanic that can back you up when you get stuck during the TG teardown.

Best of luck,

JohnMc