How to Lower Car Payment Without Refinancing

Car loans can be a major monthly expense for millions of Americans. New cars are appealing, and the general trend is to pay less up front and more on the back end--with big monthly payments. In some cases, cars cannot be refinanced--due to high mileage, age, condition or a combination of the three. In these cases, lowering your payment is considerably harder. There is one way to reduce your monthly payment without refinancing: a private debt restructure.

  • Establish a solid reason for a restructure. Usually lenders only grant these types of programs, often called "hardship" loans, if you are in serious danger of defaulting on the loan. Such reasons include: medical emergency, loss of employment and bankruptcy.

  • Calculate your own debt to income (DIR) ratio. A high DIR will cause you to struggle to make payments. Divide all of your monthly expenses by your gross monthly income. For example, if you have $1,000 in expenses each month (including a car payment), and $2,000 in gross income, your DIR is 50 percent--what lenders consider relatively high.

  • Determine your current interest rate on your car loan and figure out what would be a more manageable interest rate. Bankrate has an auto payment calculator that you can use to figure this out. It's important to have a clear request before asking for a rate modification.

  • Contact your lender and ask for a hardship plan. Be sure to provide all documentation to support your claims--income documents, bank statements--and prepare to lose the first round of negotiations. You may need to get a person in a supervisory position involved.

  • Make sure to get the hardship plan in writing before agreeing to it and signing it. Make sure the terms will help your current financial situation.

  • Prepare to rework your personal budget and spending--especially if the hardship program you get approved is only temporary. You need to make changes to your expense habits to pay off an unwieldy car loan.