Land Rover Repair: shake, surge, and misfire, best wishes for 2005, valve job


Question
-------------------------
Followup To
Question -
I have a 2000 DII with 95000 miles.  The service engine light goes on and off, and I fear my problem may actually be several problems.  A recent service visit revealed occasional misfires from cylinder 5, but the dealer could not find anything to fix.  I have heard only an occasional misfire (maybe 3 times total over several weeks), the acceleration is weak in the 25 to 45 mph range and is associated with a shake, and at high speeds it surges.  I fear that part of your answer is going to be "it's gonna cost ya," and that is ok, but my dealer has not realy gained my trust, so I am interested if you know what the problem is.
Thanks,
Scott
I am in Toledo, OH and have been taking the LR to Detroit (Farmington).  Do you have another to recommend?
Thanks
Answer -
Hi Scott,

I am aware of a serious problem with series II Disco's and sticking exhaust valves.  This may be the cause of your woes.  In order to verify this, LR would have to open up your engine and determine if this is true.  At least you have cyl. 5 to start with.

I have heard that most series II discos have this problem and it usually surfaces around 50,000 miles.   Your Disco is newer and perhaps it is just starting.  A valve job is often the remedy (about $2000US) and there is little you can do to avoid this.  Additives to fuel won't affect the exhaust side.

If you are able, find another dealership and get a second opinion.  In cases like this, you should stay with mechanics that know LR's and Disco's specifically.  More experienced mechanics should find the fault faster.

If you don't know of another dealership in your area, send me a note and a general location and I'll help you find one.

Best of luck with this problem, Scott.

JohnMc

NB:  Best wishes for 2005

Answer
*******************FOLLOW UP **************

Hi Scott,

here are some dealers I found.  The closest to you IN OHIO is first:

Land Rover Dayton
ADDRESS:  780 Miamisburg-Centerville Rd. Centerville OH  45459
PHONE:  (937) 428 4000
URL:  dayton.landroverretailer.com

Land Rover Dublin (north of Columbus,OH I believe)
ADDRESS:  6325 Perimeter Loop Road, Dublin OH  43016
PHONE:  (614) 717 4829
FAX:  (614) 889 2877
URL:  dublin.landroverretailer.com

Land Rover Cincinnati
ADDRESS:  4540 Alpine Avenue, Cincinnati OH  45242
PHONE:  (513) 791 1000
URL:  cincinnati.landroverretailer.com

East of you:

Land Rover Westside
ADDRESS:  9600 Brookpark, Cleveland OH  44129
PHONE:  (216) 351 9999
FAX:  (216) 398 3988
URL:  westside.landroverretailer.com

Land Rover Solon
ADDRESS:  6133 Kruse Drive, Solon OH  44139
PHONE:  (440) 542 0602
URL:  solon.landroverretailer.com

DON'T FEEL SO BAD....MY CLOSEST DEALER IS about 100 miles!

Best of luck with this,

JohnMc

*************** END OF FOLLOW-UP*************